Home
Party Supplies
Holiday Parties
Valentine's Day
Favors & Activities

Valentine's Day Party Favors

SORT BY

Valentine's Day Favors

    • Valentine's Day Rubber Duck
      Valentine's Day Rubber Duck
      1 1/2in x 1 3/4in Rubber Toy
      SKU: 492712
      Price: $0.59
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Valentine's Day Stampers 6ct
      Valentine's Day Stampers 6ct
      1in x 1 1/2in Stampers
      SKU: 457897
      Price: $3.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Ring Erasers 12ct
      Ring Erasers 12ct
      SKU: 607907
      Price: $3.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Valentine's Day Body Jewelry 12ct
      Valentine's Day Body Jewelry 12ct
      SKU: 458001
      Was: $2.99
      Now: $2.24
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Valentine's Day Multicolor Pen
      Valentine's Day Multicolor Pen
      3 3/4in Pen
      SKU: 607908
      Price: $0.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Candy Heart Pencil with Giant Eraser
      Candy Heart Pencil with Giant Eraser
      8in Wood Pencil
      SKU: 657410
      Was: $1.49
      Now: $1.11
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Sequin Heart Pen
      Sequin Heart Pen
      2in x 9 1/2in Fabric & Plastic Pen
      SKU: 607936
      Surprise! What will you get?
      Price: $1.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Valentine's Day Glitter Pencils 12ct
      Valentine's Day Glitter Pencils 12ct
      7 1/2in Pencils
      SKU: 550334
      Price: $3.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Valentine's Day Pencil Pack 24ct
      Valentine's Day Pencil Pack 24ct
      7 3/8in Pencils
      SKU: 184828
      Price: $5.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • 3D Valentine's Day Erasers 24ct
      3D Valentine's Day Erasers 24ct
      SKU: 409625
      Price: $5.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Heart Notepads 30ct
      Heart Notepads 30ct
      2 1/2in x 3 7/8in Paper Notepads
      SKU: 184841
      Price: $5.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Valentine's Day Krazy Straws 12ct
      Valentine's Day Krazy Straws 12ct
      10 1/2in Plastic Straws
      SKU: 409623
      Was: $5.00
      Now: $3.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability

Novelty Exchange Cards

Back to top
    • Sticker Valentine Exchange Cards 12ct
      Sticker Valentine Exchange Cards 12ct
      2 1/2in x 4in Paper Cards
      SKU: 550337
      Price: $3.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Valentine Exchange Cards with Paratroopers 12ct
      Valentine Exchange Cards with Paratroopers 12ct
      SKU: 657460
      Price: $3.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Valentine's Day Self-Inflating Balloons 4ct
      Valentine's Day Self-Inflating Balloons 4ct
      4in Foil Balloons
      SKU: 657524
      Save 10% off balloons with purchase of a helium tank
      Price: $3.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Valentine Cards with Maze Puzzles 12ct
      Valentine Cards with Maze Puzzles 12ct
      SKU: 607915
      Price: $3.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Fancy Fins Valentine Exchange Cards with Tattoos 32ct
      Fancy Fins Valentine Exchange Cards with Tattoos 32ct
      Paper Cards
      SKU: 709499
      Price: $2.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Valentine's Day Sticker Tags 30ct
      Valentine's Day Sticker Tags 30ct
      SKU: 607914
      Price: $0.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Valentine's Day Bubbles 6ct
      Valentine's Day Bubbles 6ct
      4oz Bubbles
      SKU: 657459
      Price: $3.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Butterfly Valentine Exchange Cards with Mini Pens 12ct
      Butterfly Valentine Exchange Cards with Mini Pens 12ct
      SKU: 550340
      Price: $3.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Fortune Teller Valentine Exchange Cards 20ct
      Fortune Teller Valentine Exchange Cards 20ct
      SKU: 464634
      Price: $3.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Smiley & Cupcake Valentine Coloring Books Exchange Cards 12ct
      Smiley & Cupcake Valentine Coloring Books Exchange Cards 12ct
      3 3/4in x 5in Paper Books
      SKU: 709563
      Price: $2.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Go Wild Valentine Exchange Card Puzzles 16ct
      Go Wild Valentine Exchange Card Puzzles 16ct
      3in x 2in Jigsaw Puzzles
      SKU: 709501
      Price: $2.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Moustache Valentine Exchange Cards with Krazy Straws 12ct
      Moustache Valentine Exchange Cards with Krazy Straws 12ct
      SKU: 550339
      Price: $3.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability

Tattoos & Stickers

Back to top
    • Foil Red Heart Stickers 3 Sheets
      Foil Red Heart Stickers 3 Sheets
      SKU: 15457
      Price: $0.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Valentine's Day Assorted Stickers 2 Sheets
      Valentine's Day Assorted Stickers 2 Sheets
      SKU: 335146
      Was: $1.00
      Now: $0.49
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Prismatic Valentine's Day Stickers 5 Sheets
      Prismatic Valentine's Day Stickers 5 Sheets
      SKU: 287815
      Was: $3.00
      Now: $1.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Heart Valentine's Day Bracelet Tattoos 2 Sheets
      Heart Valentine's Day Bracelet Tattoos 2 Sheets
      8 Tattoos
      SKU: 709550
      Was: $1.00
      Now: $0.49
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Smiley & Cupcake Valentine's Day Tattoos 24ct
      Smiley & Cupcake Valentine's Day Tattoos 24ct
      2in x 2in Tattoos
      SKU: 709555
      Price: $1.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Holographic Foam Heart Stickers 130ct
      Holographic Foam Heart Stickers 130ct
      3/4in x 3/4in Foam Stickers
      SKU: 607921
      Price: $3.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Valentine's Day Stickers 9 Rolls
      Valentine's Day Stickers 9 Rolls
      SKU: 184752
      Was: $3.00
      Now: $2.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Glitter Foam Heart Stickers 285ct
      Glitter Foam Heart Stickers 285ct
      SKU: 607918
      Price: $3.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Hearts Sticker Book 9 Sheets
      Hearts Sticker Book 9 Sheets
      111 Stickers
      SKU: 757431
      Price: $0.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Hearts Sticker Activity Box
      Hearts Sticker Activity Box
      4in x 8in Plastic Box
      SKU: 757410
      Price: $1.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Jumbo Hearts Sticker Book 8 Sheets
      Jumbo Hearts Sticker Book 8 Sheets
      350 Stickers
      SKU: 757390
      Price: $2.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Woodland Friends Valentine's Day Puffy Stickers 1 Sheet
      Woodland Friends Valentine's Day Puffy Stickers 1 Sheet
      4 Stickers
      SKU: 657411
      Price: $0.25
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability

Crafts & Activities

Back to top
    • Large Foam Hearts 20ct
      Large Foam Hearts 20ct
      6in x 5 3/4in Foam Decorations
      SKU: 607917
      Price: $3.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Heart Puzzle Activity Kit
      Heart Puzzle Activity Kit
      38in x 34 1/4in Paper Decoration
      SKU: 657414
      Price: $3.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Valentine's Day Activity Pads 8ct
      Valentine's Day Activity Pads 8ct
      2 1/2in x 3 1/2in Paper Notepads
      SKU: 762733
      Price: $0.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Heart Fuzzy Art Sets 16ct
      Heart Fuzzy Art Sets 16ct
      Art Supplies
      SKU: 762715
      Price: $5.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Food Valentine's Day Bingo
      Food Valentine's Day Bingo
      2 to 16 Players
      SKU: 762734
      Price: $5.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Valentine's Day Activity Pads 8ct
      Valentine's Day Activity Pads 8ct
      SKU: 550326
      Price: $0.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Valentine's Day Velvet Coloring Set
      Valentine's Day Velvet Coloring Set
      SKU: 409619
      Price: $5.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Woodland Friends Valentine's Day Bingo
      Woodland Friends Valentine's Day Bingo
      SKU: 657415
      Price: $5.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Woodland Friends Valentine's Day Party Game
      Woodland Friends Valentine's Day Party Game
      SKU: 657416
      Price: $3.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability

Gift Bags & Containers

Back to top
    • Pink & Red Heart Treat Bags 12ct
      Pink & Red Heart Treat Bags 12ct
      5in x 9 1/2in Paper Bags
      SKU: 657455
      Price: $2.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Small Key to Your Heart Treat Bags 20ct
      Small Key to Your Heart Treat Bags 20ct
      9 1/2in Cellophane Bags
      SKU: 184709
      Price: $2.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Large Key to Your Heart Treat Bags 20ct
      Large Key to Your Heart Treat Bags 20ct
      11in Cellophane Bags
      SKU: 184710
      Price: $3.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Smiley Valentine's Day Treat Bag Kit for 20
      Smiley Valentine's Day Treat Bag Kit for 20
      5in x 11 1/4in Plastic Bags
      SKU: 709520
      Price: $2.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • 3D Valentine's Day Gift Bag
      3D Valentine's Day Gift Bag
      13in x 10 1/2in x 5in Paper Bag
      SKU: 492370
      Price: $1.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Red Hearts Favor Box
      Red Hearts Favor Box
      4 1/2in Cardstock Box
      SKU: 184748
      Was: $0.99
      Now: $0.74
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Red Heart Box
      Red Heart Box
      7 3/4in x 7 3/4in x 3in Plastic Box
      SKU: 607628
      Price: $1.69
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Smiley Square Basket
      Smiley Square Basket
      5 1/4in x 5 1/4in Cardstock Basket
      SKU: 762744
      Price: $1.49
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Glitter Heart Window Treat Boxes 3ct
      Glitter Heart Window Treat Boxes 3ct
      SKU: 610254
      Price: $4.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
    • Valentine's Day Favor Box
      Valentine's Day Favor Box
      3 1/2 x 4 1/2 Cardstock Box
      SKU: 607637
      Price: $0.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Happy Valentine's Day Treat Bag
      Happy Valentine's Day Treat Bag
      5 1/4 x 10in x 3in Paper Bag
      SKU: 607636
      Price: $0.29
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Valentine's Day Treat Bags 20ct
      Valentine's Day Treat Bags 20ct
      9in Cellophane Bags
      SKU: 409613
      Price: $3.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability

Gift Wrap Accessories

Back to top
    • Red Tissue Paper 8ct
      Red Tissue Paper 8ct
      20in x 20in Paper Sheets
      SKU: 179752
      Price: $0.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability
    • Valentine's Day Adhesive Gift Tags 20ct
      Valentine's Day Adhesive Gift Tags 20ct
      SKU: 492366
      Price: $0.99
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability

Mailboxes

Back to top
    • Valentine Mailbox Kit
      Valentine Mailbox Kit
      5 3/4in x 8 3/4in x 5 3/4in Cardboard Mailbox
      SKU: 607911
      Price: $3.00
      - +
      Out Of Stock
      shipping available
      Online Only
      In-Store Check Availability