Baking Supplies

  • Characters & Themes
  • Cupcake Supplies
  • Cake Supplies
  • Cake Pop Supplies
  • Cookie Supplies
  • Candy Making Supplies
  • Baking Pans
  • Tools & Tips
  • Icing & Decorations
  • Sugar Sheets
  • Boxes & Carriers
  • Cupcake Stands
  • Cake Stands
  • Baking Party Supplies
  • Deals
of 2
View All
  • Red Baking Cups 75ct Quick View
    $1.99
    Red Baking Cups 75ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
    Review Rating: 5.00
  • Mini Red Baking Cups 100ct Quick View
    $1.99
    Mini Red Baking Cups 100ct 1 1/4in Paper Baking Cups
    Review Rating: 5.00
  • Bold Valentine's Day Baking Cups 75ct Quick View
    $1.99
    Bold Valentine's Day Baking Cups 75ct 2in Paper Cups
  • Wilton Sesame Street Baking Cups 50ct Quick View
    $2.49
    Wilton Sesame Street Baking Cups 50ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
  • Wilton PAW Patrol Baking Cups 50ct Quick View
    $2.49
    Wilton PAW Patrol Baking Cups 50ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
  • Gold Baking Cups 24ct Quick View
    $1.99
    Gold Baking Cups 24ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
    Review Rating: 3.50
  • Wilton Little Mermaid Baking Cups 50ct Quick View
    $2.49
    Wilton Little Mermaid Baking Cups 50ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
    Review Rating: 5.00
  • Wilton Minnie Mouse Baking Cups 50ct Quick View
    $2.49
    Wilton Minnie Mouse Baking Cups 50ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
    Review Rating: 4.50
  • Red Polka Dot Baking Cups 75ct Quick View
    $1.99
    Red Polka Dot Baking Cups 75ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
    Review Rating: 5.00
  • Holly Baking Cups 75ct Quick View
    $1.99
    Holly Baking Cups 75ct
    Review Rating: 5.00
    Only a Few Left!
  • Mermaid Wishes Baking Cups 75ct Quick View
    $1.99
    Mermaid Wishes Baking Cups 75ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
    Review Rating: 5.00
  • Mini Gold Baking Cups 75ct Quick View
    $1.99
    Mini Gold Baking Cups 75ct 1 1/4in Paper Baking Cups
    Review Rating: 5.00
  • Wilton Frozen Baking Cups 50ct Quick View
    $2.49
    Wilton Frozen Baking Cups 50ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
  • Magical Unicorn Baking Cups 75ct Quick View
    $1.99
    Magical Unicorn Baking Cups 75ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
  • Wilton My Little Pony Baking Cups 50ct Quick View
    $2.49
    Wilton My Little Pony Baking Cups 50ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
    Review Rating: 5.00
  • Black & Gold Polka Dot Foil Baking Cups 48ct Quick View
    $2.99
    Black & Gold Polka Dot Foil Baking Cups 48ct 2in Foil & Paper Baking Cups
  • Colorful Sprinkles Baking Cups 75ct Quick View
    $1.99
    Colorful Sprinkles Baking Cups 75ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
  • Wilton Avengers Baking Cups 50ct Quick View
    $2.49
    Wilton Avengers Baking Cups 50ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
    Review Rating: 5.00
  • Wilton Ultimate Spider-Man Baking Cups 50ct Quick View
    $2.49
    Wilton Ultimate Spider-Man Baking Cups 50ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
    Review Rating: 4.00
  • Colorful Polka Dot Foil Baking Cups 48ct Quick View
    $2.99
    Colorful Polka Dot Foil Baking Cups 48ct 2in Foil & Paper Baking Cups
  • Wilton Batman Baking Cups 50ct Quick View
    $2.49
    Wilton Batman Baking Cups 50ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
  • Wilton Rainbow Brights Baking Cups 300ct Quick View
    $7.99
    Wilton Rainbow Brights Baking Cups 300ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
    Review Rating: 1.50
  • Wilton Watercolor Baking Cups 36ct Quick View
    $2.99
    Wilton Watercolor Baking Cups 36ct 2in Foil & Paper Baking Cups
    Review Rating: 5.00
  • Zebra Baking Cups 75ct Quick View
    Now $1.00 Was:$1.99
    Zebra Baking Cups 75ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
  • Gold & White Baking Cups 150ct Quick View
    $4.99
    Gold & White Baking Cups 150ct 2in Foil & Paper Baking Cups
  • Wilton Star Wars 7 The Force Awakens Baking Cups 50ct Quick View
    $2.49
    Wilton Star Wars 7 The Force Awakens Baking Cups 50ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
    Review Rating: 4.50
  • Patriotic American Flag Baking Cups 75ct Quick View
    $1.99
    Patriotic American Flag Baking Cups 75ct 2in Foil & Paper Baking Cups
    In-Store Pickup Coming Soon
  • Hot Pink & Black Zebra Baking Cups 75ct Quick View
    Now $1.49 Was:$1.99
    Hot Pink & Black Zebra Baking Cups 75ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
    Item is excluded from additional discounts.
    Online Only
  • Wilton Smiley Baking Cups 50ct Quick View
    $2.49
    Wilton Smiley Baking Cups 50ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
  • Wilton Black Neon Polka Dot Baking Cups 36ct Quick View
    $2.99
    Wilton Black Neon Polka Dot Baking Cups 36ct 2in Foil & Paper Baking Cups
  • Wilton Minion Baking Cups 50ct - Despicable Me 3 Quick View
    $2.49
    Wilton Minion Baking Cups 50ct - Despicable Me 3 2in Paper Baking Cups
  • Red Gingham Baking Cups 50ct Quick View
    $2.29
    Red Gingham Baking Cups 50ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
    Online Only
  • Wilton Cupcake & Flower Mini Baking Cups 150ct Quick View
    $1.99
    Wilton Cupcake & Flower Mini Baking Cups 150ct 1 1/4in Paper Baking Cups
  • Wilton Kraft Baking Cups 75ct Quick View
    $1.99
    Wilton Kraft Baking Cups 75ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
  • Wilton Star Wars 8 The Last Jedi Baking Cups 50ct Quick View
    $1.99
    Wilton Star Wars 8 The Last Jedi Baking Cups 50ct 2in Paper Baking Cups
  • Communion Baking Cups 75ct Quick View
    $1.99
    Communion Baking Cups 75ct
of 2 Next
View All

Make More of Your Favorites with our Collection of Baking Accessories

Why search all around town for baking essentials when Party City has it all? We know that every good party needs good food, which is why our collection of baking supplies and accessories features hundreds of items to help create your favorite treats. Explore our selection of plain and specialty baking pans, as well as cake stands, cookie cutters, decorations and much more. We even have baking party supplies so you and your friends can have fun making delicious baked goods. Find what you need today!