Elmo 1st Birthday Party Supplies

Elmo loves you! Get ready for sunshine and smiles with our Elmo 1st Birthday Party Supplies! Party supplies feature the adorable Elmo with colorful 1st birthday messages. The Elmo 1st Birthday Party Supplies also feature Elmo 1st Birthday themed tableware, plates, napkins, cups, and party kits. Add our Elmo 1st Birthday party favors, decorations, and invitations to Elmo 1st Birthday Party Supplies for your exciting Elmo theme party! Mix and match Elmo 1st Birthday Party Supplies with our solid color tableware for a custom birthday theme.
Tableware
1st Birthday Elmo Dessert Plates 18ct
7in x 7in Paper Plates
SKU: 446564
MSRP: $7.55
Our Price: $3.77
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Elmo Dinner Plates 18ct
10in x 10in Paper Plates
SKU: 446563
MSRP: $12.55
Our Price: $6.27
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Elmo Beverage Napkins 36ct
5in x 5in Paper Napkins
SKU: 446561
MSRP: $7.59
Our Price: $3.79
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Elmo Lunch Napkins 36ct
6 1/2in x 6 1/2in Paper Napkins
SKU: 446562
MSRP: $9.99
Our Price: $4.99
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Sesame Street Cups 18ct
9oz Paper Cups
SKU: 446558
MSRP: $6.99
Our Price: $3.49
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Sesame Street Table Cover
54in x 96in Plastic Table Cover
SKU: 446560
MSRP: $7.69
Our Price: $3.84
Quantity -+
Table Cover Clips 4ct
SKU: 3880
$1.99
Quantity -+
White Table Cover Clamps 4ct
SKU: 181747
$3.99
Quantity -+
Table Clips 24ct
SKU: 318509
$5.99
Quantity -+
Cutlery
Back to top
Red Premium Plastic Forks 20ct
SKU: 66391
$2.49
Quantity -+
Red Premium Plastic Knives 20ct
SKU: 66392
$2.49
Quantity -+
Red Premium Plastic Spoons 20ct
SKU: 66393
$2.49
Quantity -+
Red Premium Plastic Cutlery Set 24ct
SKU: 113945
$2.99
Quantity -+
Red Cutlery Set 210pc
SKU: 181702
$9.99
Quantity -+
Invitations
Back to top
Elmo 1st Birthday Custom Photo Invitation
As low as $0.93 each
SKU: 532516
See Price List
Add to Basket to Customize
Elmo 1st Birthday Custom Invitation
As low as $0.93 each
SKU: 532515
See Price List
Add to Basket to Customize
Elmo First Birthday Custom Thank You Note
As low as $0.90 each
SKU: 532587
See Price List
Add to Basket to Customize
Sesame Street 1st Birthday Custom Invitation
As low as $0.93 each
SKU: 400486
See Price List
Add to Basket to Customize
Sesame Street Birthday Custom Thank You Note
As low as $0.90 each
SKU: 405759
See Price List
Add to Basket to Customize
Abby Cadabby 1st Birthday Custom Invitation
As low as $0.93 each
SKU: 400484
See Price List
Add to Basket to Customize
Abby Cadabby 1st Birthday Custom Thank You Note
As low as $0.90 each
SKU: 405758
See Price List
Add to Basket to Customize
Elmo First Birthday Custom Invitation
As low as $0.93 each
SKU: 400477
See Price List
Add to Basket to Customize
Elmo 1st Birthday Custom Thank You Note
As low as $0.90 each
SKU: 405754
See Price List
Add to Basket to Customize
1st Birthday Sesame Street Invitations 20ct
SKU: 446583
$6.99
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Sesame Street Thank You Notes 20ct
SKU: 446582
$6.99
Quantity -+
Banners
Back to top
Elmo 1st Birthday Custom Photo Banner 6ft
As low as $19.99
SKU: 532660
$10 off a custom banner on any $75 purchase with code BANNER You pay $9.99 - $19.99
each
See Price List
Add to Basket to Customize
Elmo 1st Birthday Custom Banner 6ft
As low as $19.99
SKU: 532659
$10 off a custom banner on any $75 purchase with code BANNER You pay $9.99 - $19.99
each
See Price List
Add to Basket to Customize
Elmo First Birthday Custom Banner 6ft
As low as $19.99
SKU: 429056
$10 off a custom banner on any $75 purchase with code BANNER You pay $9.99 - $19.99
each
See Price List
Add to Basket to Customize
Sesame Street 1st Birthday Custom Banner 6ft
As low as $19.99
SKU: 429062
$10 off a custom banner on any $75 purchase with code BANNER You pay $9.99 - $19.99
each
See Price List
Add to Basket to Customize
Sesame Street 1st Birthday Banners 2ct
18in Foil Balloon
SKU: 446565
$5.99
Quantity -+
Sesame Street 1st Birthday Banner
SKU: 446566
$9.99
Quantity -+
Decorations
Back to top
Sesame Street Streamer
30ft Crepe Paper Streamer
SKU: 461075
$1.99
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Sesame Street Confetti
12in x 12in Paper Decoration
SKU: 446579
$2.99
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Sesame Street Cutouts 12ct
Foil & Paper Decorations
SKU: 531712
$3.99
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Sesame Street Swirl Decorations 12ct
Paper Decorations
SKU: 446585
$4.99
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Sesame Street Lantern Garland 12ft
3ft String & Paper Decorations
SKU: 446569
$7.99
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Sesame Street Table Decorating Kit 23pc
5 1/2ft x 4 3/4in Cardstock Decoration
SKU: 446576
$5.99
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Sesame Street Room Decorating Kit 10pc
Plastic Decorations
SKU: 446571
$9.99
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Sesame Street High Chair Decorating Kit 2pc
Plastic Decorations
SKU: 446570
$5.99
Quantity -+
Sesame Street Scene Setter
SKU: 461104
$5.99
Quantity -+
Sesame Street Wall Decals
SKU: 469343
ONLINE ONLY
$12.99
Quantity -+
Elmo Wall Decals
SKU: 469341
ONLINE ONLY
$17.99
Quantity -+
Balloons
Back to top
Red Polka Dot Balloons 6ct
SKU: 450626
$2.99
Quantity -+
Happy Birthday Elmo Balloon
SKU: 21485
$2.99
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Sesame Street Balloon
SKU: 181402
$2.99
Quantity -+
Elmo Balloon - Personalized
SKU: 180368
$3.99
Quantity -+
Orbz Sesame Street Balloon 16in
SKU: 597650
$5.99
Quantity -+
Elmo Balloon
SKU: 44639
$8.99
Quantity -+
Elmo Balloon - Waving
SKU: 255999
$8.99
Quantity -+
Elmo Balloon - Singing
SKU: 159305
$9.99
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Sesame Street Balloon Bouquet 5pc
SKU: 434524
$15.99
Quantity -+
Happy Birthday Elmo Balloon Bouquet 5pc
SKU: 180408
$15.99
Quantity -+
Giant Gliding Elmo Balloon 54in
SKU: 478598
$19.99
Quantity -+
Solid Color Balloons
Back to top
Red Round Balloon
17in Foil Balloon
SKU: 44997
$1.99
Quantity -+
Red Star Balloon
19in Foil Balloon
SKU: 45008
$1.99
Quantity -+
Red Balloons 15ct
12in Latex Balloons
SKU: 237870
$2.99
Quantity -+
Apple Red Balloons 72ct
SKU: 229514
$7.99
Quantity -+
Number Balloons
Back to top
Number 1 Balloon - Silver
SKU: 552219
$9.99
Quantity -+
Number 1 Balloon - Gold
SKU: 552239
$9.99
Quantity -+
Number 1 Balloon - Celebration
SKU: 552229
$9.99
Quantity -+
Balloon Accessories
Back to top
Sesame Street Balloon Weight 5.5oz
SKU: 457374
$1.99
Quantity -+
Red Star Balloon Weight 6oz
SKU: 50034
$1.99
Quantity -+
Red Curling Ribbon
350yds Ribbon
SKU: 70175
$2.99
Quantity -+
Plastic Balloon Clips 144ct
SKU: 14131
$3.99
Quantity -+
Balloon Pump
SKU: 193
$4.99
Quantity -+
LED Balloon Lights 12ct
SKU: 412618
$9.99
Quantity -+
Hi-Float Balloon Treatment
SKU: 89075
$15.99
Quantity -+
Large Helium Tank 14.9cu ft
Ground Shipping Only
SKU: 114710
$59.99
Quantity -+
Accessories
Back to top
Elmo Hat
7in Paper Hats
SKU: 446574
$1.99
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Sesame Street Bib
10in x 13in Vinyl Bib
SKU: 446581
$3.99
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Sesame Street Party Hats 8ct
SKU: 446573
$3.99
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Sesame Street Blowouts 8ct
SKU: 446578
$3.99
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Sesame Street Straws 12ct
24 Stickers
SKU: 446586
$4.99
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Sesame Street Hat
104 Stickers
SKU: 531714
$5.99
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Sesame Street Autograph Photo Mat
14in x 10 3/5in Paper Frame
SKU: 531713
$6.99
Quantity -+
Favors
Back to top
Sesame Street Tattoos 1 Sheet
SKU: 461116
$0.99
Quantity -+
Sesame Street Memory Games 4ct
SKU: 461085
$2.99
Quantity -+
Sesame Street Bubbles 6ct
SKU: 461119
$2.99
This item is currently out of stock
Sesame Street Krazy Straws 12ct
SKU: 461113
$4.99
Quantity -+
Sesame Street Whistles 12ct
SKU: 461076
$5.99
Quantity -+
Sesame Street Favor Pack 48pc
SKU: 461099
$9.99
Quantity -+
Favor Containers
Back to top
Sesame Street Favor Cup 16oz
16oz Plastic Cup
SKU: 461077
$0.99
Quantity -+
Sesame Street Favor Container
SKU: 461118
$1.49
Quantity -+
1st Birthday Sesame Street Favor Bags 8ct
SKU: 446580
$2.99
Quantity -+
Elmo Party Bags with Ties 16ct
SKU: 184009
$2.99
Quantity -+
Cake & Cupcake Supplies
Back to top
Number 1 Royal Blue Glitter Birthday Candle 3in
SKU: 586048
$1.49
Quantity -+
Number 1 Bright Pink Glitter Birthday Candle 3in
SKU: 550361
$1.49
Quantity -+
Number 1 Polka Dot Birthday Candle 3in
SKU: 50176
$0.99
Quantity -+
Number 1 Polka Dot Birthday Candle with Glitter 5in
SKU: 400382
$3.99
Quantity -+
Number 1 Birthday Candle and Cupcakes 5ct
SKU: 550345
$3.99
Quantity -+
Number 1 Birthday Candle and Stars 3ct
SKU: 97082
$3.99
Quantity -+
Sesame Street 1st Birthday Candle
SKU: 446567
$3.99
Quantity -+
Elmo Birthday Cake Candle 3in
SKU: 60458
$3.99
Quantity -+
Elmo Cupcake Picks 12ct
SKU: 408156
$2.49
Quantity -+
Elmo Icing Decorations 9ct
SKU: 30647
$2.99
Quantity -+
Red Icing Tube 4.25oz
SKU: 5129
$1.99
Quantity -+
Red Color Mist
Ground Shipping Only
SKU: 251346
$3.79
Quantity -+
Silver 16in Round Cardboard Platter
SKU: 186132
$1.99
Quantity -+
Silver 14in x 21in Cardboard Platter
SKU: 186131
$2.49
Quantity -+
Round Performance Cake Pan 12in
SKU: 5093
$10.99
Quantity -+
Performance Cake Sheet Pan 12in x 18in
SKU: 5089
$15.99
Quantity -+
Elmo Baking Cups 50ct
SKU: 60463
$2.49
Quantity -+
Red Polka Dots Baking Cups 75ct
SKU: 442961
$1.99
Quantity -+
Elmo Cupcake Stand Holds 24
SKU: 407805
$7.99
Quantity -+
Elmo Cupcake Kit For 24
SKU: 455624
Individually Priced: $18.95
Kit Savings: Over 10%!
$16.99
Quantity -+
Recipe Right 12 Cup Muffin Pan
SKU: 184022
$6.99
Quantity -+
Elmo Cake Pan 13in
SKU: 60452
$12.99
Quantity -+
Pinatas
Back to top
Pull String Sesame Street Pinata 23in
SKU: 185825
$19.99
This item is currently out of stock
Pull String Elmo Pinata 20in
SKU: 165519
$19.99
Quantity -+
Pull String Cookie Monster Pinata 20in
SKU: 216222
$19.99
Quantity -+
Giant Elmo Pinata 36in
Ground Shipping Only
SKU: 459543
$39.99
Quantity -+
Giant Big Bird & Friends Pinata 36in
Ground Shipping Only
SKU: 471496
$34.99
Quantity -+
Kiddie Mix Candy 240pc
Net Wt. 64oz
SKU: 45732
$9.99
Quantity -+
Pinata Candy & Toys 160pc
Net Wt. 32oz
SKU: 18049
$10.99
Quantity -+
Farley's Kid's Mix Candy 365ct
Net Wt. 69oz
SKU: 493004
$14.99
Quantity -+
Farley's Kids Combo Candy 230pc
Net Wt. 48oz
SKU: 224192
$14.99
Quantity -+
Pinata Blindfold
SKU: 18047
$1.49
Quantity -+
Pinata Bat 30in
SKU: 18046
$4.99
Quantity -+
Gift Wrap
Back to top
Red Tissue Paper 8ct
24in x 20in Paper Sheets
SKU: 179752
$0.99
Quantity -+
Red Gift Bag
9 1/2in x 8in x 4in
SKU: 14079
$0.99
Quantity -+
3D Glitter Balloons Gift Bag
17in x 12 1/2in x 6in
SKU: 446647
$3.99
Quantity -+
Sesame Street Gift Wrap
8ft x 30in Paper Wrap
SKU: 583627
$3.49
Quantity -+
Costumes & Accessories
Back to top
Baby Elmo Costume - Sesame Street Deluxe
Costume #008
SKU: 175008
008
$29.99
Quantity -+
Toddler Girls Frilly Elmo Costume - Sesame Street
Costume #1459
SKU: P445006
1459
$24.99
Quantity -+
Toddler Boys Elmo Costume Deluxe - Sesame Street
SKU: P100250
Save 25%
ONLINE ONLY
Was: $39.99
Now: $30.00
Quantity -+
Toddler Girls Frilly Elmo Light Up Costume - Sesame Street
SKU: P537281
ONLINE ONLY
$39.99
Quantity -+
Toddler Boys Elmo Light Up Costume - Sesame Street
SKU: P537265
ONLINE ONLY
$44.99
Quantity -+
Toddler Girls Frilly Cookie Monster Costume - Sesame Street
Costume #1458
SKU: P444999
1458
$19.99
Quantity -+
Toddler Boys Light Up Cookie Monster Costume - Sesame Street
Costume #054
SKU: P537278
054
$39.99
Quantity -+
Toddler Boys Cookie Monster Costume Deluxe - Sesame Street
SKU: P321095
Save 10%
ONLINE ONLY
Was: $44.99
Now: $40.00
Quantity -+
Toddler Girls Abby Cadabby Costume - Sesame Street
SKU: P414881
Save 30%
ONLINE ONLY
Was: $29.99
Now: $20.00
Quantity -+